Recently, North Carolina passed HB2, a law that states that transgender people must use the bathroom assigned to their biological sex. Reactions have varied throughout the nation. One of the most profound replies to the bill being passed is famous musicians cancelling concerts in North Carolina in protest. Other than this, a city called Oxford in Alabama has taken action and modeled the Tar heel state. They issued an ordinance stating, “single sex public facilities are places of increased vulnerability and present the potential for crimes against individuals utilizing those facilities which may include, but not limited to, voyeurism, exhibitionism, molestation and assault and battery.” The Oxford City Council passed this ordinance right after Target announced they would let transgender employees and customers use the bathrooms they feel comfortable with. Alabama wanted to be heard and they achieved just that. This law isn't lenient, either. Violating it could cause 6 months in jail or a whopping $500 fine. Outraged at these new rules, the Human Rights Campaign spoke out saying, "This anti-transgender law is unprecedented in its establishment of criminal penalties for violations of the law, and raises a myriad of privacy and legal concerns, including questions about how the law will be enforced." Despite varying opinions, HB2 is making its mark on America.
In my opinion, I think HB2 is just another restraint put on transgender people. A law made by people who don't know the struggles of being transgender can only lead to controversy in the name of misrepresentation. Who is going to speak up for transgenders in places like the deep south? No one. Personally, I think this bill is uncannily similar to disputes over abortion rights. Both sides have valid points, but ultimately, abortion and which bathroom to use are decisions of women and transgenders only. Why should we rely on congressmen and women to choose the fates of a demographic that is so vastly underrepresented in politics?
This relates to class because we recently talked about state rights. The 10th amendment speaks about state rights and federalism. Also, we talked about how a bill is created. First, a bill is drafted and a congressman or woman introduces it. Next, it is referred to committee (where most bills die) and it is marked up. Then, a date is set for the bill to be talked about in front of the house. Finally, both houses have to pass the bill and the President either vetoes or signs it.